Misdiagnosed Paediatric Epilepsy: Medico‑Legal Insights for Clinical Negligence Claims

By Dr Mike Taylor, Consultant Paediatric Neurologist

Posted 29 May 2025

7 Minute Read

Child sits calmly during a paediatric EEG exam, supporting gentle neurological assessment with specialist brain-activity monitoring.

Early epilepsy misdiagnosis can weaken breach and causation. This article gives solicitors expert insights to spot errors, strengthen claims, and secure better client outcomes.

Epilepsy in children is frequently misunderstood in the early pathway - seizure activity can be mistaken for trauma, febrile episodes or behavioural issues. Diagnostic delay and mismanagement carry lifelong consequences for neurological development and care needs, directly influencing breach, causation, and quantum. Neurology expert evidence is essential to clarify seizure types, genetic syndromes and treatment protocols, and to assess whether opportunities for earlier intervention were missed.


Watch the full webinar here >


Diagnostic Red Flags & Early Pathway


  • Epilepsy is not a single diagnosis. Each syndrome has distinct prognoses and protocols. Ensure expert reports specify the likely subtype and the reasoning.


  • Dravet Syndrome: often begins with febrile seizures at 5-8 months. Early features are commonly misattributed to benign convulsions or focal epilepsy. Delays increase seizure burden and neurodevelopmental harm.


  • Infantile spasms: still missed - sometimes misread as reflux or startle. Even 2-4 week delays may carry long‑term consequences.


Medico‑Legal Considerations


  • Breach: Were red flags recognised? Were referrals, imaging, EEG and genetic tests actioned promptly? Did management align with the suspected epilepsy subtype?


  • Causation: If inappropriate therapy worsened seizures (e.g., sodium‑channel blockers in suspected Dravet), did this materially contribute to harm?


  • Quantum: Consider the lifelong impact of delayed control on development, education, and care requirements.


Case Examples & Outcomes (Illustrative Patterns)


  • Contraindicated medication pre‑diagnosis leading to avoidable hospitalisations and neurological decline.


  • Delayed SCN1A testing deferring access to targeted treatments (e.g., cannabidiol, fenfluramine) and comprehensive care planning.


  • Failure to escalate status epilepticus (beyond ~5 minutes) contrary to APLS pathways, contributing to hypoxic brain injury.


Key Takeaways for Solicitors


  • Pin the specific epilepsy subtype early in instructions and expert reports.


  • Map the timeline: parental concern → first presentation → investigations → referral → treatment → outcomes.


  • Test treatment logic: did chosen drugs fit the working diagnosis at the time?


  • Verify genetic testing thresholds and timing; document any impact on therapy options and prognosis.


  • Compare actions to published pathways (e.g., escalation for prolonged seizures) when analysing breach.


Quote Highlights


“Epilepsy subtypes drive management - generic labels risk generic care.”

“Growth in precision medicine raises the standard: staying current with guidelines is part of reasonable care.”

“In status epilepticus, minutes matter - delays in escalation can be indefensible.”


Access our panel of 87 Paediatric Neurology Expert Witnesses >

Tags:

  • Paediatric Epilepsy
  • Epilepsy Litigation
  • Seizure Mismanagement
  • Delayed Diagnosis
  • Neurologist Expert Witness

Expert Disciplines:

  • Neurology

About The Author

mike-taylor-paediatric-neurologist.png

Dr Mike Taylor

Consultant Paediatric Neurologist

Dr Mike Taylor is a leading Consultant Paediatric Neurologist at Leeds Children’s Hospital, with specialist expertise in epilepsy, Dravet Syndrome, and complex neurological diagnoses. A recognised expert witness, he brings clarity to medico-legal cases involving seizure mismanagement, SUDEP risk, and diagnostic delay.

From the Blog

Related Articles

Patient undergoing an MRI scan, representing the diagnostic process and medico-legal considerations in post-traumatic epilepsy cases.
Blog6 min read

Gain expert insight into assessing post-traumatic seizure risk in head injury claims - vital for accurate prognosis, liability, and compensation in clinical negligence cases.

Surgeons performing an operation, reflecting precision, accountability, and the clarity needed in understanding clinical negligence law.
Blog5 min read

Help clients grasp complex clinical negligence issues with clear, expert-backed explanations - empowering solicitors to communicate effectively, manage expectations, and strengthen case outcomes with confidence.

Mike Taylor Header
Webinar5 min read

Misdiagnosed epilepsy can derail paediatric claims. In this expert webinar, Dr Mike Taylor shares how to spot red flags, prove breach, and strengthen causation in epilepsy-related clinical negligence cases.

Find out why 70+ legal firms partner with INNEG.

Request a callback, or contact us.

INNEG respects your privacy. Any information you share with us will be used only to respond to your query.

Thank you for your request!

We will get back to you as soon as possible.

Misdiagnosed Paediatric Epilepsy: Expert Medico-Legal Insights | INNEG