Hand Trauma in PI Claims: Mr Rupert Wharton, Consultant Ortho Surgeon

By Mr Rupert Wharton, Consultant Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgeon

Posted 16 December 2024

10 Minute Read

In this on-demand webinar, Consultant Trauma & Orthopaedic Surgeon Mr Rupert Wharton explores the medico-legal complexities of hand and wrist injuries. From functional loss to psychological impact, he highlights how expert assessment can separate genuine trauma from degeneration or exaggeration.


About the Speaker


Mr Rupert Wharton is a Consultant Trauma & Orthopaedic Surgeon based in London, specialising in hand and wrist pathology. He treats both trauma and elective conditions and provides medico-legal reports in personal injury cases. He holds British and European diplomas in Hand Surgery and draws on evidence-based literature in clinical and legal analysis.


Access our panel of 1,519 Orthopaedic Surgery Expert Witnesses >


Webinar Highlights: Key Medico-Legal Insights


  • Thumb stability loss can be severely disabling - even with minor range-of-motion reduction.
  • Middle and index fingers are essential for precision; ring/little fingers influence grip strength.
  • Surface anatomy helps identify potential nerve damage from lacerations.
  • PROMs like DASH and PEM scores can uncover inconsistencies or signs of exaggeration.
  • Common confounders include pre-existing asymptomatic arthritis and malingering behaviour.


Case Highlights


  • Ulnar Shaft Fracture: A straightforward fracture from a road traffic collision with suboptimal healing. Clear causation, predictable prognosis, and literature-based outcome reporting.
  • Ligament Injury Post-Uber Collision: A delivery rider with delayed treatment and high PEM score but relatively low DASH score. Hand calluses suggested continued use. Mr Wharton flagged discrepancies for further evaluation.
  • SLAC Wrist Misattribution: A 63-year-old with wrist arthritis and ligament instability. Historic x-rays showed degenerative changes predating the accident. Expert literature cited to argue that the injury was not causative but possibly precipitant.
  • Possible Malingering Case: A 75-year-old with fluctuating knee symptoms inconsistent with prior records and physical presentation. Mr Wharton raised the possibility of functional overlay or dishonesty.


Read the full medico-legal article here >

Tags:

  • Orthopaedic Expert Witness
  • Orthopaedic Trauma
  • Missed Fractures
  • Trauma
  • Fracture Misdiagnosis

Expert Disciplines:

  • Orthopaedic Surgery

About The Author

Mr Rupert Wharton  Consultant Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgeon

Mr Rupert Wharton

Consultant Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgeon

Mr Rupert Wharton is a London-based Consultant Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgeon with expertise in hand and wrist injuries. He holds UK and EU hand surgery diplomas and regularly advises on personal injury litigation.

From the Blog

Related Articles

Max Mifsud Webinar
Webinar5 min read

Growth plate injuries often go under the radar in paediatric claims - yet their long-term consequences can be severe. In this expert webinar, Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon Mr Max Mifsud explores how subtle injuries can evolve into complex litigation.

Doctor examining a spinal X-ray, highlighting the critical role of orthotics in rehabilitation and spinal injury management.
Blog5 min read

Understand how orthotic interventions shape spinal injury rehabilitation outcomes - essential for identifying overlooked care needs, building stronger claims, and maximising compensation accuracy.

Surgeons focused during a procedure, representing multidisciplinary teamwork and legal issues surrounding brain surgery and informed consent.
Blog5 min read

Gain expert insights on neurosurgical clinical negligence, MDT challenges, and evidence essentials to strengthen your cases and navigate complex claims with confidence and precision.

Find out why 70+ legal firms partner with INNEG.

Request a callback, or contact us.

INNEG respects your privacy. Any information you share with us will be used only to respond to your query.

Thank you for your request!

We will get back to you as soon as possible.